Are Former Adventists Really "Lucifer, Cain, and Judas"?



SDA Pastor Randy Skeete said: 

"The greatest enemy of Adventists are former Adventists. Who tried to kill Christ in heaven? Lucifer. Who seduced Adam to sin? His wife. Who killed Abel? What was the relationship? His brother. Who told Abraham, "Go sleep with Hagar"? His wife. Who deceived Isaac when he was blind? His wife and his son. What am I try— Who betrayed Christ? A disciple. Your greatest enemy is the person close to you. Mhm. Personally, and on the church level, listen to me: the greatest enemy of Adventists are former Adventists. Mhm. Oh, yes. Ellen White says we have more to fear from within than without. How do we handle such people? We remember, first of all, God still loves them. And some people drift and come back. The same way God is long-suffering, always desiring the sinner to come back, we must try to adopt the same attitude without sustaining them in what they're doing or allowing their behavior to contaminate us. But at no time can we decide that person is cut off. Only God can cut you off. We must pray, be Christians, be Christlike, be loving, but never endorse whatever they're doing, and don't allow them to affect us. But always believe God may bring that person back. God finally converted Paul. No one would have guessed that could happen. God finally converted Nebuchadnezzar. People do come back. God gives a second chance; we must be willing to do the same. So let's not put ourselves on a pedestal and look down on people, but we're not sharing in their behavior, in their false beliefs, but we're praying that God will open their eyes and bring them back. A lot of soul-winning has to be done in the church. Mhm. There are people in the pews, but out of Christ. A lot of soul-winning needs to occur in the church."

If you have been scrolling through Facebook lately, you have probably seen a viral Reel making the rounds among our Seventh-day Adventist (SDA) friends. In it, well-known SDA evangelist Pastor Randy Skeete looks straight into the camera, accompanied by a chorus of solemn "Mhm"s from the congregation, and drops what he clearly thinks is a theological bombshell:

"The greatest enemy of Adventists are former Adventists."

To prove his point, Pastor Skeete launches into a rapid-fire biblical quiz show. He lines up Lucifer, Eve, Cain, Sarah, Rebekah, Jacob, and Judas Iscariot, concludes that "your greatest enemy is the person close to you," quotes Ellen G. White, and then advises Adventists on how to handle us "contaminated" ex-Adventists while praying we come back to the fold like Nebuchadnezzar and the Apostle Paul.

At Former Adventists Philippines (FAP) where we live by the banner "Freed by the Gospel. Firm in the Word", we don't respond to videos like this out of bitterness. Many of the people sharing Pastor Skeete's clip are our own parents, spouses, siblings, and lifelong friends. We love them deeply. Calling people who simply opened their Bibles, tested SDA doctrines against Scripture, and walked into the freedom of the New Covenant gospel your "greatest enemy" is not just pastorally reckless; it is a masterclass in logical fallacies and self-defeating theology.

Let's break down Pastor Skeete's viral clip point by point, test his logic, turn his own illustrations right back around, and see where the biblical truth actually lands.

Point 1: The "Lucifer-Eve-Cain-Judas" Lineup (And How It Collapses Into Absurdity)

Let’s look at Pastor Skeete’s opening argument verbatim:

"The greatest enemy of Adventists are former Adventists. Who tried to kill Christ in heaven? Lucifer. Who seduced Adam to sin? His wife. Who killed Abel? What was the relationship? His brother. Who told Abraham, 'Go sleep with Hagar'? His wife. Who deceived Isaac when he was blind? His wife and his son. ... Who betrayed Christ? A disciple. Your greatest enemy is the person close to you. Mhm. Personally, and on the church level, listen to me: the greatest enemy of Adventists are former Adventists."

At first listen, if you are sitting in the pews nodding "Mhm," that sounds dramatic and profound. When you slow down and actually think about what he just did, you realize he stacked three massive logical fallacies on top of each other:

1. The Fallacy of False Analogy (Faulty Comparison): He takes a list of people who committed murder, marital folly, deception, or cosmic treason against God, and equates them with Christians who left a 19th-century American denomination because its doctrines failed the test of Scripture.

2. Poisoning the Well & Guilt by Association: Before a former Adventist can even open a Bible to ask a question about 1844, the Investigative Judgment, or the New Covenant, Pastor Skeete has already painted them with the brush of Lucifer, Cain, and Judas. That way, members won't listen to our actual biblical arguments; they will just see horns and a pitchfork.

3. The Fallacy of Equivocation (Category Error): He quietly swaps "leaving the Seventh-day Adventist Church organization" with "betraying Jesus Christ." To make that analogy work, Pastor Skeete has to assume that the SDA Church is equivalent to Jesus Christ in heaven and on earth. That is institutional idolatry dressed up as church loyalty.

Let's take Pastor Skeete's core premise seriously for a second: "Your greatest enemy is the person close to you." Look at his evidence:

* Adam's wife (Eve) seduced him.
* Abraham's wife (Sarah) gave him terrible advice.
* Isaac's wife (Rebekah) and son (Jacob) tricked him.
* Abel's brother (Cain) murdered him.

Wait a minute, Pastor Skeete, if that is how biblical logic works, what is the practical takeaway for Adventist families this Saturday? Should Adventist husbands start sleeping with one eye open because " Who seduced Adam, Abraham, and Isaac? Their wives!"? Should every Adventist elder look across the Sabbath potluck table at his biological brother and hide the metal forks because "Who killed Abel? His brother!"? Should blind grandpas lock their doors whenever their wives and sons bring them a bowl of savory stew?

See how ridiculous that becomes the moment you test it? Eve, Sarah, Rebekah, Cain, and Judas were not "former members" who left a denomination over theology:
  • Eve, Sarah, and Rebekah never became "Former Wives." They stayed married to Adam, Abraham, and Isaac the entire time!

  • Cain didn't leave a church to start a "Former Abelites Podcast"; he murdered his brother because Cain's own works-based offering was rejected while Abel's blood sacrifice was accepted by faith (Hebrews 11:4).

  • Judas didn't leave the twelve disciples to preach salvation by grace alone; he was the group treasurer stealing from the money bag while pretending to be a loyal insider (John 12:4–6)!
The Boomerang Effect: What About Former Catholics and Former Methodists?

Now let's throw Pastor Skeete's boomerang and watch it fly right back into the SDA pulpit.

If leaving the religious group you were once close to makes you the "greatest enemy," a spiritual traitor, and a modern-day Judas, what does that make every single person Pastor Randy Skeete baptizes during his evangelistic crusades?

Think about it! When a Roman Catholic, a Baptist, or a Methodist attends an SDA tent crusade or Revelation Seminar, leaves their childhood church, and gets baptized into the Seventh-day Adventist Church, what do they immediately become? They become Former Catholics, Former Baptists, and Former Methodists! And what is the very first thing the SDA church trains them to do? Go back to their Catholic or Evangelical families to tell them why they left!

Even better: Who founded the Seventh-day Adventist Church?
  • Ellen G. White was a former Methodist.
  • James White was a former member of the Christian Connection.
  • Joseph Bates was a *former Christian Connection member.
  • Martin Luther, whom Adventists love to hero-worship in The Great Controversy, was a former Roman Catholic monk and priest who exposed the errors of his former church!
By Pastor Skeete's own logic, was Martin Luther the "Judas" of Catholicism? Was Ellen White the "Lucifer" of Methodism? Every time Pastor Skeete hands out a baptismal certificate to someone leaving another denomination, is he running a recruitment center for "traitors"? You cannot celebrate people leaving other churches to join yours as "courageous truth-seekers," and then turn around and call people who leave your church for biblical Christianity "Lucifer and Judas." That is a textbook Double Standard (Special Pleading).

Point 2: The Ellen White Misquote That Boomerangs Straight Into the SDA Pews

Next, Pastor Skeete appeals to Adventism's favorite tie-breaker: "Ellen White says we have more to fear from within than without."

Let's check the actual historical source. Ellen White wrote in the Review and Herald on March 22, 1887 (later compiled in Selected Messages, Book 1, p. 122):

"We have far more to fear from within than from without. The hindrances to strength and success are far greater from the church itself than from the world."

Wait a second. Read that sentence again very carefully, and let’s ask a simple question of basic English grammar:

Where are former Adventists located, "within" the SDA church, or "without" (outside) the SDA church?

That's right, by definition, the word former means we are no longer within! We walked out the door! Many of us had our names officially dropped from the SDA church books, or we voluntarily sent in our resignation letters. We are outside ("without")!

So when Ellen White warned in 1887 that the SDA church has "more to fear from within than from without" and that the greatest hindrances come " from the church itself", she wasn't talking about ex-Adventists at all! She was talking about current Seventh-day Adventists inside the church the pastors, administrators, elders, and members still sitting in the pews!

In fact, Pastor Skeete accidentally proves he misapplied Ellen White's quote by contradicting himself at the very end of his own video:

"A lot of soul-winning has to be done in the church. Mhm. There are people in the pews, but out of Christ."

Boomerang! At the start of his 90-second clip, the greatest threat is former Adventists (who are outside the pews). By the end of the clip, the crisis is the unconverted Adventists sitting in the pews, out of Christ! Pastor Skeete misused an Ellen White quote about internal church hypocrisy to scapegoat people who already left.

Point 3: "Don't Let Their Behavior Contaminate Us" (The Myth of the Sin-Loving Ex-Adventist)

How does Pastor Skeete tell Adventists to treat us? Listen closely to his pastoral prescription:

"How do we handle such people? We remember, first of all, God still loves them. And some people drift and come back. The same way God is long-suffering, always desiring the sinner to come back, we must try to adopt the same attitude without sustaining them in what they're doing or allowing their behavior to contaminate us. ... We must pray, be Christians, be Christlike, be loving, but never endorse whatever they're doing, and don't allow them to affect us."

Notice the Straw Man Fallacy and Begging the Question (Circular Reasoning) hidden inside that pious-sounding advice:

Pastor Skeete automatically assumes that anyone who leaves Seventh-day Adventism has "drifted into sin," become a backslidden "sinner," and adopted a lifestyle of toxic "behavior" that might "contaminate" pure, holy Adventists.

Let’s have some real talk here. Why does the Adventist system always have to tell its members that people leave because they "got offended," "drifted away from God," or "just wanted to eat pork and break the Sabbath"? Because the SDA system cannot afford to admit the real reason thousands of pastors, elders, and devoted members are leaving across the Philippines and around the world.

We didn't leave Adventism because we wanted to sin. We didn't "drift" out of laziness. Most of us were the ones teaching Sabbath School, preaching from the pulpit, leading Pathfinders, and defending the church! We left because we studied the Bible in context.

We discovered that on the cross, when Jesus cried "It is finished" (John 19:30), He actually finished the atonement; He didn't wait until October 22, 1844, to start a second phase of work in heaven.

We discovered in Hebrews 7–10, Galatians 3–4, and 2 Corinthians 3 that the Old Covenant, written on tablets of stone, complete with its shadow Sabbath (Colossians 2:16–17), was fulfilled and obsolete in Christ, replaced by a far more glorious New Covenant where the Spirit writes the law of Christ on our hearts.

We discovered that salvation isn't a probation exam where our lifetime record is audited in an Investigative Judgment, but a blood-bought gift where believers have already "passed from death into life" and "shall not come into judgment" (John 5:24).

And what about that word "contaminate"? Isn't that pure Old Covenant Pharisaism? In the Gospels, the Pharisees were terrified of ceremonial "contamination" from outsiders, whereas Jesus was accused of eating with sinners. Yet when it comes to former Adventists who are now thriving in Christ-centered, Bible-teaching New Covenant churches, what exactly is the "contamination" Pastor Skeete is so afraid of?

He isn't afraid you'll catch us robbing banks. He is afraid our Bible verses will "contaminate" your 1844 charts. When a church leader tells you, "Be nice to them, say hello, pray for them, but don't let them affect you!", that is code for: "Whatever you do, don't listen to their biblical reasons for leaving, because we don't have an exegetical answer for them!"

Point 4: The Paul and Nebuchadnezzar Boomerang

Then comes Pastor Skeete’s grand historical comparison:

"But always believe God may bring that person back. God finally converted Paul. No one would have guessed that could happen. God finally converted Nebuchadnezzar. People do come back. God gives a second chance; we must be willing to do the same. So let's not put ourselves on a pedestal and look down on people, but we're not sharing in their behavior, in their false beliefs, but we're praying that God will open their eyes and bring them back."

Pause right there. Calling on Adventists "not to put ourselves on a pedestal and look down on people" right after comparing former Adventists to Lucifer, Cain, Judas, unconverted Saul of Tarsus, and pagan King Nebuchadnezzar eating grass in a field is like slapping someone in the face and saying, "Now let's not be aggressive!"

Look closer at his example of the Apostle Paul. This is the ultimate boomerang against Seventh-day Adventism!

Who was Saul of Tarsus before God converted him on the road to Damascus?
  • Was Saul a worldly pagan eating unclean food and breaking the seventh-day Sabbath? No!

  • In Philippians 3:5–6, Paul describes his pre-conversion life: "circumcised the eighth day, of the stock of Israel, of the tribe of Benjamin, a Hebrew of the Hebrews; concerning the law, a Pharisee; concerning zeal, persecuting the church; concerning the righteousness which is in the law, blameless."
Before his conversion, Saul of Tarsus was a strict seventh-day Sabbath-keeper, a strict dietary-law keeper, and a fierce defender of Old Covenant law-keeping who viewed Christians preaching grace apart from the Mosaic Law as the "greatest enemy"!

And what happened when Jesus converted Paul on the road to Damascus? Did Paul "come back" to Pharisaic law-keeping? No! Paul became a "Former Pharisee"! He left the legalistic religious system of his fathers, counted all his law-keeping credentials as rubbish (Philippians 3:8), and spent the rest of his life writing letters like Galatians, Romans, Colossians, and Hebrews to rescue people from going back under the Old Covenant law!

So when Pastor Skeete brings up the conversion of Paul, the boomerang hits bullseye:
  • Saul before conversion = zealous, Sabbath-keeping, dietary-law-enforcing religious insider who viewed grace-preachers as the enemy.

  • Paul after conversion = a "former insider" who discovered the sufficiency of Jesus Christ and was immediately labeled the #1 enemy by his former Sabbath-keeping synagogue buddies (Acts 9:23; 21:28)!
Who in this story actually looks like pre-conversion Saul, and who looks like post-conversion Paul?

3 Mic-Drop Cross-Examinations to Checkmate This Argument

Next time an SDA friend, elder, or pastor sends you Pastor Skeete’s video or repeats the line that "former Adventists are the greatest enemy of Adventists," don't get angry. Smile warmly, grab a cup of coffee, and ask them these three cross-examination questions:

Mic-Drop Question #1: The "Evangelistic Boomerang" Dilemma

"Pastor, if leaving the church you were once close to and exposing its doctrinal errors makes someone the equivalent of Lucifer, Cain, and Judas, then were Martin Luther (a former Catholic priest), Ellen G. White (a former Methodist), and every single convert you baptize out of Catholic or Evangelical churches also 'Judases' and 'Lucifers' to the churches they left? If you say YES, then your own SDA pioneers and converts are traitors. If you say NO, because they left error to follow biblical truth, then you just admitted that leaving a denomination isn't betrayal at all, and the only real question is whether SDA doctrine holds up to the Bible!"

Mic-Drop Question #2: The "Pauline Conversion" Dilemma

"In Galatians 4:16, the Apostle Paul, who was himself a 'former Pharisee, ' asked the church: 'Have I therefore become your enemy because I tell you the truth?' When former Adventists open the Bible and show from Hebrews 8–10, Colossians 2:14–17, and Romans 3–5 that Jesus completed the atonement on the cross and inaugurated the New Covenant, what specific crime makes us your 'greatest enemy'? Are we your enemy because we hate you, or, like Paul, have we only become your 'enemy' because our open Bibles threaten 1844 and Ellen White?"

Mic-Drop Question #3: The "Christ vs. Denomination" Dilemma

"Pastor Skeete equates leaving the Seventh-day Adventist Church with Lucifer attacking Christ and Judas betraying Christ, and says ex-Adventists need to 'come back' like pagan King Nebuchadnezzar. Tell me plainly: Is the Seventh-day Adventist denomination identical to Jesus Christ Himself? If a former Adventist trusts exclusively in the finished cross-work of Jesus, is born again by the Holy Spirit, loves the Word of God, and fellowships in a Bible-believing New Covenant church, are they 'out of Christ' simply because their name is no longer on an SDA church roster? If you say YES, you have replaced Jesus with a denomination. If you say NO, then why is Pastor Skeete comparing born-again believers in Christ to Judas Iscariot and unconverted pagans?"


A Final Pastoral Word to Our Adventist Friends

To our dear Seventh-day Adventist family members, friends, and pastors watching reels like Pastor Skeete's: we are not your enemies.

We don't wake up in the morning plotting against you. We wake up thanking Jesus that the veil in the temple was torn from top to bottom (Matthew 27:51), that our sins are blotted out right now by His blood, not waiting for a courtroom audit that started in 1844, and that we can rest in the finished work of our Savior every single day of the week (Hebrews 4:3, 9–10).

When we speak up, write articles, or record podcasts at Former Adventists Philippines, we do it for the exact reason Pastor Skeete accidentally admitted in the final ten seconds of his video: because there are so many precious people sitting in the pews who are exhausted, fearful, and still unsure if they are truly saved in Christ. We know that feeling, because we used to sit in those exact same pews. And our prayer is not that you would hate your church, but that you would fall so deeply in love with the all-sufficient Jesus of the New Testament that no fear-mongering video could ever keep you from examining the Scriptures for yourself.

FORMER ADVENTISTS PHILIPPINES

​“Freed by the Gospel. Firm in the Word.”

Support this ministry

  • GCash: 0969-514-3944

  • PayPal: paypal.me/formeradventistsph










Comments