If you’ve spent any time talking with Seventh-day Adventists online, you’ve seen the verse list. They string together twenty passages about loving God, keeping His commandments, and following the example of Jesus to argue that Christians are still required to keep Saturday.
On the surface, it looks persuasive. Nobody wants to argue against loving Jesus or thanking Him for our salvation.
The problem isn't the Bible verses they cite; it’s how they read them. If you pull a verse out of its historical setting, ignore who was speaking to whom, and skip right over which covenant was in effect at the time, you can make the Bible say almost anything. Reading a text in its actual historical and grammatical context (historico-grammatical hermeneutics) and checking the original Hebrew and Greek changes the picture completely. In fact, when you look closely at the text, every single point in this standard SDA argument boomerangs right back on them.
Let’s walk through their claims one by one.
1. The "If You Love Me, Keep Saturday" Argument (And the "Fruit of Salvation" Scam) (Ref: 1 John 3:22; 1 John 5:3; Psalm 119:47; John 14:15; Ephesians 2:8–10)
The argument opens by claiming that Adventists don't keep the Sabbath to get saved, but as an expression of gratitude and the "fruit" of their salvation, because we are "saved by grace through faith" (Ephesians 2:8–10) and Jesus said if we love Him, we will keep His commandments (John 14:15).
Hold on right there. Before we even look at the Greek text, we need to call out a massive bait-and-switch fallacy and self-refuting claim right out of the gate.
How can an Adventist claim that keeping Saturday is the "fruit" of their salvation when, according to official SDA theology, they aren't even saved yet?
Look at what Ellen G. White explicitly taught in Christ’s Object Lessons (p. 155):
"Those who accept the Saviour, however sincere their conversion, should never be taught to say or to feel that they are saved."
Read that again. Your own prophetess says you should never say or feel that you are saved! So when an SDA looks a Christian in the eye on Facebook and says, "We are already saved by grace, and keeping the Sabbath is just the fruit of our salvation," what is going on here? Are you finally admitting that Ellen White taught false doctrine, or are you claiming that you are somehow "more saved" than Ellen White herself?
It gets even worse when you bring in the 1844 Investigative Judgment, the core doctrine of the SDA Church. According to Adventism, Jesus entered the Most Holy Place in 1844 to investigate the life records of every professed believer to determine who actually kept the law well enough to be worthy of eternal life. According to your own theology, that heavenly courtroom trial isn't finished yet! Nobody knows when their name comes up on the docket, and no final verdict is given until probation closes in the future.
Think about the absurdity of that: how can you announce the verdict ("We are saved by grace!") before the trial in heaven is even over? How can Sabbath-keeping be the "fruit" of your salvation when the tree of your salvation hasn't even passed the 1844 inspection yet? You can't pick apples off a tree that hasn't been declared alive! Every time SDAs tell people, "We're already saved by grace just like you, and Saturday is only the fruit," they are running a theological scam, borrowing Evangelical words they don't actually believe just to hook unsuspecting Christians under the law.
Now look at what they do with the Bible verses in this opening point. In logic, this is called equivocation and begging the question (petitio principii). The writer quietly assumes that every time the word "commandments" shows up in John's writings, it automatically means the Old Covenant Ten Commandments, specifically Saturday. He assumes the very thing he needs to prove.
If you open the Greek New Testament to John 14:15 and 1 John 3:22, you’ll see that John doesn't use the word nomos (νόμος), which is his standard term for the Law of Moses. Whenever John talks about the Mosaic Law, he uses nomos and contrasts it with the grace and truth that came through Jesus (John 1:17). Instead, in John 14:15 and 1 John 3:22, he uses entolē (ἐντολή), which refers to the specific teachings and instructions of Christ.
You don't even have to guess what John means by entolē in 1 John 3:22, because he defines it in the very next verse (1 John 3:23): God's command for us is to believe in the name of His Son Jesus Christ and love one another. Nothing about Saturday. Yes, Ephesians 2:8–10 says we truly are saved by grace and created for good works, and as New Covenant believers who actually have assurance of salvation (1 John 5:13), our works are guided by the Law of Christ (ennomos Christou, 1 Corinthians 9:21; Galatians 6:2), not the stone tablets of Sinai.
Think about what happens if we turn their "commandments" logic back on them. If "loving God means keeping His commandments" flattens the entire Bible so that every command God ever gave applies to Christians today, why stop at Saturday? God commanded Noah to build an ark out of gopher wood. He commanded Abraham to circumcise every male in his house. He commanded Israel to tie blue tassels (tzitzit) onto the corners of their clothes (Numbers 15:38).
So if I walk into an Adventist church on Saturday morning, should I ask the pastor why there isn't a 450-foot wooden boat in the parking lot, or where the four blue tassels are on his suit jacket? The moment he says, "Hold on, those commands were given under a different covenant," he just proved our entire point.
2. The Creation Rest Argument (Ref: Genesis 2:1–3)
Next, they argue we have to keep the seventh day because God blessed it, set it apart, and rested on it at Creation.
Reading the Saturday Sabbath law of Exodus 20 back into Genesis 2 is a textbook case of anachronism and an argument from silence. You cannot read a law into a text where no law exists.
Look at Genesis 2:1–3 in Hebrew. The text uses the verb shabath (שָׁבַת), which simply means "to cease" or "to stop." Two things jump right off the page:
1. The noun Shabbath: the name of the weekly Sabbath day, isn't there. In fact, it doesn't appear anywhere in Genesis. You won't find a single line about Adam, Enoch, Noah, Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, or Joseph ever keeping a Sabbath.
2. There is no imperative verb, no command, telling Adam and Eve to rest. God is the only one who ceased from His work, because He was finished creating.
Even better, do the simple math right from the text: God’s seventh day in Genesis 2 was NOT Adam and Eve’s seventh day!
When did God create Adam and Eve? Near the end of the sixth day (Genesis 1:26–31). That means God’s sixth day was Adam and Eve’s first day of life. When the sun went down and God’s seventh day began (Genesis 2:1–3), what day was it for Adam and Eve? It was only their second day of existence!
Think about how absurd it gets when SDAs try to force the fourth commandment ("Six days you shall labor and do all your work, but the seventh day is the Sabbath") onto Adam and Eve in Genesis 2. How could God's seventh day be Adam's seventh-day rest after six days of labor when Adam had only been alive for a few hours? Imagine Adam waking up on his very first morning on earth, less than 24 hours after being formed out of dust, and saying to Eve, "Phew, honey, I'm exhausted from existing since yesterday afternoon! Let's take a day off from those six days of work we never did!"
And notice how this completely wrecks the SDA calendar argument: if Adam actually had to work six days before resting on his seventh day, then Adam's seventh day wouldn't even fall on God's seventh day! The text is crystal clear: Genesis 2:1–3 is talking strictly about God’s seventh day after God’s six days of creating, not a weekly calendar handed to humanity.
Now flip the rest of their Genesis 2 argument around. In Genesis 2:1–3, God worked on Days 1 through 6, and He rested on Day 7, with zero command given to humans. So if Genesis 2 obligates us to copy what God did on His Day 7 even without a command, shouldn't it also obligate us to copy what God did on His Days 1 through 6?
Why do SDAs only imitate God's Day 7 schedule? Before you claim God's Genesis 2 rest on Saturday, shouldn't you speak light into existence on Sunday, separate the atmosphere on Monday, raise up dry land on Tuesday, hang a few galaxies on Wednesday, invent whales on Thursday, and sculpt a human out of dirt on Friday afternoon? How can you insist on copying God's Day 7 rest when you skipped His Day 1 through 6 work?
Why did Moses mention God blessing the seventh day when he wrote Genesis? Because Moses wrote Genesis for the Israelites at Mount Sinai to give them the backstory for the covenant sign God had just handed them in Exodus 16 and 20. Moses makes this plain in Deuteronomy 5:2–3, where he tells Israel that God did not make the Sinai covenant (which starts with the Ten Commandments in verse 6) with their forefathers, the Patriarchs, but only with the Israelites standing alive at that mountain. And in Hebrews 4:3–10, the New Testament explains why God's seventh day in Genesis 2 has no "evening and morning" closing formula: God's creation rest points to an ongoing eternal rest that we enter every day by faith in Christ's finished work, not by clocking out for 24 hours once a week.
3. The "No Personal Pleasure or Own Words" Argument (Ref: Isaiah 58:13–14)
Then they quote Isaiah 58:13–14, telling Christians to turn away from doing their own pleasure or speaking their own words on God's holy day.
Using Isaiah 58 as a rulebook for New Testament Christians combines contextomy (quote-mining a verse out of context) with special pleading (enforcing a text on others while ignoring what it demands of you).
In Isaiah 58, the prophet is prosecuting a rib (רִיב), an Old Covenant legal lawsuit, against the nation of Judah for breaking the Mosaic covenant. You can see the covenant setting right in verse 14, where God promises that if Judah obeys, He will feed them with the heritage of their father Jacob, a direct reference to national prosperity in the land of Canaan under the blessings and curses of Deuteronomy 28.
Look at the Hebrew requirements in verse 13: aso chephetz (עֲשׂוֹת חֵפֶץ), which means pursuing your own affairs or desires, and daber davar (דַּבֵּר דָּבָר), which literally means "speaking a word", talking about your own everyday topics or plans.
Let's turn Isaiah 58:13 right back on the person who posted it. If this verse is a binding law for Christians today, do Adventists actually keep it?
From Friday sundown to Saturday sundown, do you completely stop pursuing your own interests and speaking your own words? When everyone sits down for Saturday potluck lunch at church, is the fellowship hall dead silent? Are people only chanting the Psalms in Hebrew? Or are folks chatting about their jobs, family news, the weather, and who brought the best vegetarian haystacks?
Better yet: when an Adventist spends Saturday afternoon on Facebook debating non-Adventists in the comments section, aren't they typing their own words for their own pleasure? By their own proof-text, they are breaking the Sabbath in the middle of trying to defend it.
4. The "Sign of God's People & Lord's Day" Argument (Ref: Exodus 20:8–11; Deuteronomy 5:12–15; Ezekiel 20:12, 20; Mark 2:28)
Next, the post claims the Sabbath is the sign of God as Creator and Deliverer, the sign of God's people, and because Jesus is "Lord of the Sabbath" (Mark 2:28), Saturday is "the Lord's Day."
There are two major logical fumbles packed into this paragraph: a covenantal category error (mixing up the signs of different covenants) and a semantic shift fallacy (pretending two completely different Greek phrases mean the exact same thing).
First, in Exodus 31:16–17 and Ezekiel 20:12, the Hebrew word for "sign" is oth (אוֹת). And who does God say this sign is between? Explicitly between Yahweh and the children of Israel. Throughout Scripture, every covenant has its own distinct sign:
- Noahic Covenant: The rainbow (Genesis 9:13)
- Abrahamic Covenant: Circumcision (Genesis 17:11)
- Mosaic/Sinai Covenant: The seventh-day Sabbath (Exodus 31:16–17)
- New Covenant: The Lord's Supper, where Jesus explicitly calls the cup the new covenant in His blood (Luke 22:20; 1 Corinthians 11:25), and the indwelling Holy Spirit who seals every believer (Ephesians 1:13–14).
Second, look at Deuteronomy 5:15, which the post cites. Moses commands Israel to keep the Sabbath because they were slaves in Egypt and Yahweh brought them out.
Third, when Jesus says the Son of Man is Lord (Kyrios, Κύριος) of the Sabbath in Mark 2:28 (and Matthew 12:8), read the story! The Pharisees had just accused His disciples of breaking the Sabbath by picking grain. Jesus didn't side with the Sabbath police; He put them in their place. He pointed out that David ate the consecrated bread and that priests work in the Temple every Sabbath without guilt because "something greater than the temple is here" (Matthew 12:6). Saying He is Kyrios of the Sabbath isn't Jesus locking the Church into Saturday; it's Jesus pulling rank as the Sovereign Master who fulfills and supersedes the Sabbath shadow.
And you cannot equate "Lord of the Sabbath" (Mark 2:28) with "the Lord's Day" in Revelation 1:10. In Revelation 1:10, John doesn't write "the Sabbath of the Lord." He uses a unique Greek phrase: tē kyriakē hēmera (τῇ κυριακῇ ἡμέρᾳ), literally, "the Lordly Day." That Greek adjective kyriakos ("belonging to the Lord") only shows up twice in the entire New Testament: once for the Lord's Supper (kyriakon deipnon, 1 Corinthians 11:20) and once for the Lord's Day (kyriakē hēmera, Revelation 1:10). Both point straight to the New Covenant and Jesus' resurrection on the first day of the week (Acts 20:7; 1 Corinthians 16:2).
Now watch the boomerang: you cited Deuteronomy 5:15 to tell Christians today to keep Saturday because God brought them out of Egyptian slavery. Quick question: when did any of us haul mud bricks for Pharaoh along the Nile River?
And if Jesus calling Himself "greater than the Temple" and "Lord of the Sabbath" in Matthew 12 means we have to keep the Sabbath institution intact, why don't we have to keep the Temple sacrificial system intact too? When is your next flight to Jerusalem with a spotless goat in your carry-on bag?
5. The "Jesus and Paul Kept It" Argument (Ref: Luke 4:16; Matthew 5:17; 1 Peter 2:21; Acts 17:2)
Finally, they argue that Jesus kept the Sabbath (Luke 4:16), left us an example to follow (1 Peter 2:21), and Paul kept the Sabbath as his custom (Acts 17:2), so Christians should do the same.
This is the descriptive-to-prescriptive fallacy paired with classic cherry-picking. Just because a historical passage describes Jesus or Paul doing something in a first-century Jewish setting doesn't make it a permanent law for the Church, especially when SDAs ignore 99% of the other Jewish customs Jesus and Paul practiced.
Why did Jesus observe the Mosaic Law during His earthly ministry? Paul answers that in Galatians 4:4–5: Jesus was "born under the law (hypo nomon) to redeem those who were under the law." Before the cross, the Old Covenant was still legally in effect. When Jesus said in Matthew 5:17 that He came to fulfill (plērōsai, πληρῶσαι) the Law and the Prophets, that Greek word means to bring something to its intended completion and prophetic climax, which He accomplished through His death and resurrection (Luke 24:44; John 19:30).
What about 1 Peter 2:21 telling us to follow Jesus' example (hypogrammon)? Go read 1 Peter 2:19–24 in context. Peter isn't talking about what day of the week Jesus went to the synagogue. He's talking about enduring unjust suffering without retaliating when people mistreat you!
And what about Paul going to the synagogue on the Sabbath "as his custom was" in Acts 17:2? Read the whole sentence in Acts 17:1–3: Paul went into the synagogue of the Jews to reason with them from the Scriptures that Jesus was the Messiah. That wasn't a Christian worship service; that was evangelism. Paul went to the Jewish synagogue on Saturday for the exact same reason a fisherman goes to the lake when the fish are biting, because that's where the Jewish community was gathered in one room. When Paul met with Christians to break bread, they gathered on the first day of the week (Acts 20:7; 1 Corinthians 16:2). And when Paul wrote his letters to the churches, he explicitly told believers in Colossians 2:16–17 not to let anyone pass judgment on them over a Sabbath day (sabbatōn), because those days were only a shadow (skia), whereas the reality (sōma) belongs to Christ (see also Romans 14:5–6).
Think about how inconsistent this "follow their customs" argument really is. If following the example of Jesus and Paul means copying every Old Covenant Jewish practice recorded in the Gospels and Acts, why don't Adventists copy the rest of the list?
- Jesus was circumcised on the eighth day (Luke 2:21), wore kosher tassels on the edge of His cloak (Matthew 9:20), celebrated Hanukkah in Jerusalem (John 10:22), paid the two-drachma Temple tax (Matthew 17:27), and ate a roasted Passover lamb with bitter herbs (Luke 22:8, 15).
- Paul shaved his head at Cenchreae for a Jewish vow (Acts 18:18), circumcised Timothy (Acts 16:3), and paid for four men to offer animal sacrifices for purification in the Jerusalem Temple (Acts 21:23–26).
Why grab one Jewish custom from Luke and Acts while throwing the rest out the window? And if Paul visiting a synagogue on Saturday to preach to unbelievers makes Saturday worship a permanent law for the Church, what happens if a missionary visits a local night market every Friday evening "as his custom" to preach the Gospel to street vendors? Does "Friday Night Street Food" suddenly become a requirement of the Christian faith?
3 Cross-Examination Questions for Our Adventist Friends
Before anyone drops another copy-pasted verse list in the comments, I’d love for our SDA friends to answer three simple questions straight from the text of Scripture:
1. The "No-Fire and Death Penalty" Question (Exodus 31:14–15; 35:2–3):
You insist that the Sinai Sabbath command is eternal, unchanging law for Christians today. Yet in that exact same Sinai covenant, God explicitly defined how the Sabbath must be kept: no lighting a fire in any of your homes on Saturday (Exodus 35:3) and the mandatory death penalty for anyone who works or gathers sticks on it (Numbers 15:32–36). By what biblical authority do you spark the ignition in your car, turn on your stove, and run the church air-conditioning on Saturday, and drop the penalty of the law, without admitting what Hebrews 7:12 and 8:13 plainly teach: that when the priesthood changed under Christ, there was necessarily a change of the law, making the first covenant obsolete?
2. The "Royal Priesthood" Question (Matthew 12:5 & 1 Peter 2:9):
In Matthew 12:5, Jesus proved from the Torah that the priests in the Temple "profane the Sabbath" every single Saturday by doing double the work of sacrifices (Numbers 28:9–10), yet remain completely guiltless because Temple service outranks the Sabbath day. Since the New Testament declares that every born-again believer is now a royal priest (1 Peter 2:9; Revelation 1:6) offering spiritual sacrifices continually through Jesus our High Priest (Hebrews 13:15; Romans 12:1), how can a New Covenant royal priest be bound by an Old Covenant Sabbath regulation when even Levitical priests were exempt from Sabbath rest while on duty in God's house?
3. The "Feasts, New Moons, and Sabbaths" Question (Colossians 2:16–17):
In Colossians 2:16–17, Paul tells Christians not to let anyone judge them regarding a festival, a new moon, or a Sabbath day (sabbatōn), because these are only a shadow of things to come, while the substance belongs to Christ. Adventists always try to dodge this verse by claiming "Sabbath days" here only refers to annual ceremonial feast days, not the weekly Saturday Sabbath. Here is the problem: in the Old Testament, the three-part sequence "feasts/festivals, new moons, and Sabbaths" is a standard Hebrew idiom for the entire Jewish calendar, annual (feasts), monthly (new moons), and weekly (seventh-day Sabbaths) (see 1 Chronicles 23:31; 2 Chronicles 2:4; 31:3; Nehemiah 10:33; Ezekiel 45:17; Hosea 2:11). Can you show us even one verse in the entire Old Testament where that three-part phrase ("feasts, new moons, and Sabbaths") is used and the word "Sabbaths" does not refer to the weekly seventh-day Sabbath?
The seventh-day Sabbath was a shadow pointing ahead to the real rest we have in the finished work of Jesus (Hebrews 4:3, 9–10). Once the Bridegroom is standing right in front of you, you don't go back to hugging His shadow on the wall. Rest in Jesus—He is our true Sabbath every day of the week.
FORMER ADVENTISTS PHILIPPINES
“Freed by the Gospel. Firm in the Word.”
Support this ministry
GCash: 0969-514-3944
PayPal: paypal.me/formeradventistsph

Comments
Post a Comment