Lesson 7: “Now Hear This!” ... Or “Now Hear Ellen White?” An Analysis of the November 7-13 Sabbath School Lesson from a New Covenant Perspective



If you sat through the Seventh-day Adventist Sabbath School Lesson #7 for November 7–13, titled "Now Hear This!", you probably felt that familiar tightness in your chest. On the surface, the lesson looks like a standard Bible study on Moses, Jeremiah, Jesus, and Paul, built around the memory text in 1 Corinthians 10:11 (NASB): "Now these things happened to them as an example, and they were written for our instruction, upon whom the ends of the ages have come."

For six straight days, from Sabbath afternoon to Thursday, the author walks you through stories of stubborn Israelites, wicked kings, and hypocritical Pharisees who rejected God's messengers. Then Friday hits, and the real agenda comes out. You don't even have to guess what the curriculum writers were doing, because the Teacher's Comments admit it plainly: "This lesson can help lay a foundation for understanding the acceptance, and rejection, of Ellen G. White's prophetic ministry". And if you look at Question 8 in the back of the teacher's edition, you see what really has them worried: "How should those who highly value Ellen G. White's prophetic ministry respond to the aggressive and hostile campaign against her on YouTube and through other venues?"

Let's walk through this lesson day by day, the way we should have been allowed to read it in Sabbath School, with an open Bible, sound historical-grammatical exegesis, and our eyes wide open to the logical fallacies being used to keep members in line.

Sabbath Afternoon (November 7): The Classic Bait-and-Switch

The lesson opens by talking about how people today love to speak "their truth," and then asks what happens when those personal feelings clash with "the Truth, Jesus Christ, and His Written Word". Any Christian reading that opening paragraph is going to nod in agreement. We all believe Jesus and the Bible are our final authority.

But watch how fast the sleight of hand happens in the third paragraph. The author pivots from "His Written Word" to talking about how "divine prophetic guidance was not optional" for God's people, calling it "lifesaving instruction". In logic, this is a classic Bait-and-Switch (Equivocation). You bait the hook with Jesus and the Written Word of Scripture on Saturday, and by Friday you swap the definition of "prophetic guidance," so it means the extra-biblical Testimonies of Ellen G. White.

When we read the Bible through New Covenant Theology, that swap falls apart immediately. Hebrews 1:1–2 tells us that while God spoke to the fathers through the prophets in many portions and in many ways in the past, in these last days He has spoken to us in His Son. Jesus Christ isn't just another link in a prophetic chain that eventually leads to 19th-century Battle Creek, Michigan. He is the culmination of prophecy. If Jesus Christ and the apostolic Scriptures are already the complete Truth, why does Adventism insist that you still need a Victorian author to give you "lifesaving instruction"?

Sunday (November 8): "Anger at God's Messenger" and the Kadesh-Barnea Guilt Trip

Sunday's study looks at Numbers 13:26–30 and 14:4–11, where the Israelites panicked at Kadesh-Barnea and turned on Moses and Aaron. The lesson calls Moses and Aaron "the human representatives of God's ultimate Lordship" and notes that the people rebelled by seeking new leaders to replace God's chosen prophet. Right in the middle of the biblical text, the lesson drops a quote from Ellen White's Patriarchs and Prophets (p. 389): "When men yield their hearts to unbelief they place themselves under the control of Satan, and none can tell to what lengths he will lead them".

Do you see the False Equivalence and Poisoning the Well happening here? First, the lesson quietly puts Ellen White in the shoes of Moses, the mediator of the Old Covenant who spoke with God face-to-face (Deut. 34:10–12). Second, by dropping that quote about Satan right there, the quarterly poisons the well against anyone who has doubts. Before you even get to examine the evidence for Ellen White on Friday, you're already told that "unbelief" toward God's messenger puts you "under the control of Satan".

Let's apply sound exegesis here. We don't have to guess how the New Testament applies Numbers 14, because Hebrews 3:7–4:11 quotes it directly. The warnings in Hebrews 3 and 4 are dead serious: real believers must persevere in faith and guard against an unbelieving heart that falls away from the living God (Heb. 3:12). But what was the "rest" Israel failed to enter, and how do we enter it today? Hebrews 4:3 says, "For we who have believed enter that rest." In the New Covenant, unbelief isn't questioning an uninspired denominational figurehead; unbelief is refusing to rest in the finished work of Jesus Christ! Even more, Hebrews 3:1–6 explicitly contrasts Moses as a servant in God's house with Jesus as the Son over God's house. When a church uses Kadesh-Barnea to make you afraid that questioning Ellen White hands your mind over to Satan, is that honest Bible teaching, or is it spiritual manipulation?

Monday & Tuesday (November 9–10): "Destroying the Message" and Covenant Confusion

Monday and Tuesday focus on King Jehoiakim slicing up and burning Jeremiah's scroll (Jer. 36:20–31) and King Zedekiah refusing to humble himself before Jeremiah, "who spoke from the mouth of the LORD" (2 Chron. 36:12, 15–16). Monday's lesson says of Judah, "The Lord was seeking to save them, but they had to obey", and warns us that "our disdain only intensifies the harm that will befall us and our families because of our willful ignorance or rebellion" Tuesday cites 2 Peter 3:9 and ends with a pointed question: "They mocked the messengers of God, despised God's words, and scoffed at His prophets. Surely, we today would never do anything like that—or would we?"

Logically, this is Begging the Question (Petitio Principii) combined with an Appeal to Fear (Argumentum ad Baculum). You cannot warn church members that ignoring a prophet will bring divine harm down on their families, and then apply that to Ellen White on Friday, until you first prove from Scripture that Ellen White actually spoke: "from the mouth of the LORD". Threatening people's families with disaster if they question a prophetess is fear-mongering, plain and simple.

Look also at Monday's line: "The Lord was seeking to save them, but they had to obey." That single sentence shows how badly Adventism mixes up the Old and New Covenants. Jeremiah was a covenant prosecutor enforcing the national, geopolitical curses of the Mosaic Law (Deut. 28) on the kingdom of Judah before the Babylonian invasion. Under New Covenant Theology, the saving grace of God in 2 Peter 3:9 brings sinners to repentance and justifying faith in Christ's blood, not law-keeping to earn or keep our salvation.

And since Monday's lesson makes such a big deal about King Jehoiakim cutting up a prophet's scroll to hide inconvenient words, let's talk about real Adventist history. Who actually cut up and hid alleged "prophetic" writings in Adventism? When James and Ellen White published A Sketch of the Christian Experience and Views of Ellen G. White in 1851 (now in Early Writings), they quietly excised and deleted the embarrassing passages from her 1847 visions in A Word to the "Little Flock," where she taught the "Shut Door" doctrine, the false claim that probation for the whole world had ended in October 1844. If cutting lines out of a prophetic scroll made King Jehoiakim a rebel against God, what does it say about early Adventist leaders who quietly took the scissors to Ellen White's own visions?

Wednesday (November 11): "Hypocrisy" and the AD 70 Boomerang

Wednesday's lesson looks at Matthew 23:30–35, where Jesus calls out the scribes and Pharisees as "whitewashed tombs". They polished the monuments of the dead prophets and claimed they never would have killed them, all while plotting to murder the Messiah standing right in front of them. The lesson notes that "they wanted to be associated with the power and pathos of the prophets but not the content of their messages".

Why did the lesson cut off the reading at verse 35 instead of reading one more verse? In Matthew 23:36, Jesus drops the gavel: "Truly I say to you, all these things will come upon this generation." When you use standard historical-grammatical hermeneutics and read Matthew 23, Jesus isn't just giving a timeless talk on bad manners. He is delivering the final covenantal indictment against first-century apostate Israel for shedding the blood of the Old Testament prophets and His own blood. And right on schedule, within that exact biblical generation of forty years, judgment fell in AD 70 when the Roman legions leveled Jerusalem and burned the Old Covenant Temple to the ground.

Wednesday's lesson actually boomerangs right back onto Adventism. The first-century Pharisees were obsessed with building memorials to past prophets and policing Sabbath rules, yet they missed the Messiah whom all the prophets pointed to. Today, institutional Adventism builds visitor centers and estates to honor Ellen White, yet teaches that Jesus' blood on the cross didn't finish the atonement in AD 30, insisting He had to wait until October 22, 1844, to start an Investigative Judgment in heaven. Who is really repeating the error of Matthew 23: the former Adventist who trusts completely in the finished cross of Christ, or the system that puts a 19th-century prophetess between the believer and the sufficiency of Jesus?

Thursday (November 12): "For Our Admonition," Partial Preterism, and Postmillennial Hope

Thursday brings us to the core text in 1 Corinthians 10:6–12, where Paul says Israel's wilderness failures were written down for our instruction, "upon whom the ends of the ages have come". The lesson then jumps back to the Old Testament to quote 2 Chronicles 20:20, telling us that "if only we heed the admonitions of Scripture and the prophetic messages sent by Him to us through His prophets. If we listen, learn, and obey, our lives will be established, and we will prosper". Then, quoting 1 Corinthians 10:11 again, the author asks: "If that were true back then, how much more should those words apply to us today?"

Hold on right there. Look at that question: "If that were true back then, how much more should those words apply to us today?" That question completely misses what Paul actually wrote in the Greek text. When Paul told the first-century church in Corinth that "the ends of the ages have come" (ta telē tōn aiōnōn katēntēken) upon them, he used the perfect active indicative verb katēntēken. That means the overlap and climax of the covenantal ages had already arrived in the first century! Through a New Covenant lens, "the ends of the ages" isn't talking about 1844 or 2026; it refers to the closing down of the Old Covenant Mosaic age (which Hebrews 8:13 said was "becoming obsolete and growing old, ready to vanish away" before vanishing in AD 70) and the inauguration of the New Covenant Kingdom age.

This also changes our whole outlook on history when seen through a biblical view. Notice how the Teachers' Comments frame history as just waiting around in the final stage before the end. In contrast, the Scripture recognizes that when the Old Covenant age ended in the first century, the risen Christ sat down on His throne at the Father's right hand, where He must reign until He has put all His enemies under His feet (1 Cor. 15:25). We aren't cowering in a wilderness bunker waiting to fail; Christ's New Covenant Kingdom is actively advancing across the globe as the Gospel leavens the nations.

And don't miss the Contextomy (Proof-Texting) in Thursday's lesson. Read 1 Corinthians 10:6–12 for yourself. What four sins of Israel does Paul actually warn the Corinthians against? Idolatry, sexual immorality, testing Christ, and grumbling. Does Paul say a single word in 1 Corinthians 10:6–12 about rejecting prophets? Not one word. That's why the lesson writer had to reach back to the Old Testament, yank 2 Chronicles 20:20 out of context, and tape it onto 1 Corinthians 10, because Paul's actual text had nothing to do with defending Ellen White!

Friday (November 13) & Teachers' Comments: Testing Ellen White Through a Continuationist Lens

On Friday ("Receiving and Delivering Her Messages"), the lesson lays all its cards on the table. Citing Arthur White and James White's 1868 book Life Incidents (pp. 271–274), the lesson argues that Ellen White experienced "supernatural phenomena while in vision" just like biblical prophets: she was "utterly unconscious of everything transpiring around her," she didn't breathe, her muscles went "rigid," and her "joints fixed," her eyes stayed open, and afterward she would "temporarily lose sight".

Next, Friday quotes Ellen White's own words from Testimonies for the Church (vol. 4, pp. 231–232): "God has set me as a reprover of His people; and... He will make those to whom this message is given responsible for the manner in which they treat it." Then comes the wildest claim in the entire quarterly: "Interestingly, many of those who rejected her prophetic messages did so based on their own unbelief or personal disagreements with Ellen G. White, rather than on theological grounds".

In the Teachers' Comments, the authors double down. They quote pioneer Uriah Smith (1868) accusing critics of Ellen White's visions of having "the blindest prejudice, the intensest hate, and most malignant bitterness", while praising the "fourfold fruit" of her ministry: upholding moral standards, leading people to Christ, directing readers to the Bible, and bringing comfort. They also single out former Adventist minister Dudley M. Canright, who left in 1887 and wrote Life of Mrs. E. G. White, blaming him and the internet for spreading plagiarism charges and criticisms globally.

Adventist apologists usually assume that if you reject Ellen White, you must be a Cessationist who doesn't believe in spiritual gifts. Not here! As Continuationists, we believe with all our hearts that the Holy Spirit still gives spiritual gifts, including the gift of prophecy (1 Cor. 12:7–11; 14:1–5), to build up the body of Christ today. In fact, it is precisely because we take the New Testament's teaching on spiritual gifts seriously that we have to reject Ellen White's claims:

First, in 1 Corinthians 14:3, Paul defines the purpose of New Covenant prophecy: "one who prophesies speaks to men for edification and exhortation and consolation." New Covenant prophecy is given to encourage and strengthen the local church, never to invent new doctrines, rewrite the book of Hebrews, or set up an infallible denominational "reprover" whose writings become a test of fellowship.

Second, in 1 Corinthians 14:32, Paul gives a clear rule for how New Covenant prophets operate: "and the spirits of prophets are subject to prophets." A true New Covenant prophet stays conscious and in control of their faculties. James White's description of Ellen White going "utterly unconscious," not breathing, with "rigid" muscles, "fixed" joints, open, staring eyes, and temporary blindness afterward violates 1 Corinthians 14:32. Medically, neurologists and doctors who have reviewed those exact symptoms point out that they match complex partial seizures (temporal lobe epilepsy) resulting from the severe traumatic brain injury she suffered when hit in the face with a stone at age nine.

Third, in 1 Corinthians 14:29 and 1 Thessalonians 5:20–21, Paul commands Continuationist believers: *"Do not despise prophetic utterances. But examine everything carefully; hold fast to that which is good" and "let two or three prophets speak, and let the others pass judgment." In the New Testament, testing a prophet against Scripture isn't rebellion; it's obedience! By comparing people who test and reject Ellen White to King Jehoiakim burning Jeremiah's scroll, the Sabbath School lesson actually forbids you from obeying the Apostle Paul.


Look at the stack of logical fallacies on Friday and in the Teachers' Comments:

Using Ellen White's own claim in Testimonies, vol. 4 ("God has set me as a reprover...") to prove that God set her up as a reprover is textbook Circular Reasoning. And claiming that people rejected her out of "personal disagreements... rather than on theological grounds" is a massive straw man and historical revisionism. Why did Dudley Canright and thousands of us on YouTube walk away from Ellen White? We left on concrete theological and biblical grounds:

1. She taught the false Shut Door doctrine for years after 1844, claiming probation had closed for the entire world.

2. She endorsed the Investigative Judgment, which flatly contradicts Hebrews 6:19–20 and 9:12, 24 by denying that Jesus entered the Most Holy Place when He ascended in AD 30.

3. She taught in The Great Controversy (pp. 422, 485) that Satan (Azazel) is the final sin-bearer who carries the sins of the saved at the end of time, robbing Jesus of His glory as our sole sin-bearer (1 Pet. 2:24).

4. She failed the test of Deuteronomy 18:22 in her May 1856 vision (Testimonies, vol. 1, pp. 131–132), where she prophesied that some of the believers sitting in that 1856 conference room would be translated alive to heaven when Jesus returned, and every single one of them died in the 19th and 20th centuries.

5. As researchers like Walter Rea and Ronald Numbers documented (confirming Canright's early observations), she engaged in massive literary plagiarism, copying page after page from uninspired historians and religious writers while claiming the scenes were shown to her directly by God in vision.

Instead of answering any of those theological facts, the Teachers' Comments fall back on Ad Hominem attacks and Bulverism, quoting Uriah Smith to call critics hateful and bitter and quoting Ellen White blaming "Satan" for any exposure of her errors. And here is the ultimate irony: the quarterly brings out Uriah Smith as its star witness to prove that Ellen White's visions "lead people to Christ". Have the lesson writers forgotten that in 1868, Uriah Smith himself was a committed semi-Arian who denied the eternal deity of Jesus Christ and taught that Jesus was a created being? If Ellen White's visions were so great at leading people to the true Christ, why didn't they even lead her top apologist to believe that Jesus is eternal God?

Three Mic-Drop Cross-Examination Questions for Your Sabbath School Class

If you're talking with Adventist family members, elders, or pastors about this week's lesson, don't let them put you on the defensive. Ask them these three calm, direct cross-examination questions:

1. The "Shut Door" Scroll Question (On Monday's Lesson, Jeremiah 36)

"Since Monday's lesson teaches that King Jehoiakim sinned against God by cutting out and destroying parts of Jeremiah's scroll that embarrassed him, why did James and Ellen White quietly cut out and delete the 'Shut Door' passages from Ellen White's 1847 visions when they reprinted them in Early Writings in 1851? If every word of a true prophet comes straight 'from the mouth of the LORD', why did the White Estate have to edit God's mouth?"

2. The Berean vs. Rebellion Dilemma (On Friday's Lesson & Continuationism)

"In 1 Thessalonians 5:20–21 and 1 Corinthians 14:29, Paul commands us not to despise prophecy, 'but examine everything carefully' and 'let the others pass judgment.' Yet this entire lesson claims that people who examine Ellen White's writings and conclude she isn't a biblical prophet are rebelling against God just like ancient Israel. If we aren't allowed to arrive at a 'No' verdict without being accused of yielding our hearts to Satan, how is this lesson allowing Adventists to actually obey Paul's command to test the prophets?"

3. The "Theological Grounds" Challenge (On Friday's Claim & YouTube Critics)

"Friday's lesson claims that people rejected Ellen White's messages 'based on their own unbelief or personal disagreements... rather than on theological grounds', and Question 8 warns about YouTube critics. When former Adventists on YouTube open the Bible to Hebrews 9:12 and 9:24 to show that Jesus entered the Most Holy Place in AD 30, having obtained eternal redemption, whereas Ellen White says He didn't enter the Most Holy Place until October 22, 1844, is comparing Hebrews 9 with Ellen White just a 'personal disagreement', or is it standing on the Written Word of God?"

Brothers and sisters, don't let Lesson #7 intimidate you. We don't need to fear losing our safety by stepping out from under the shadow of Battle Creek. In the New Covenant, we have a greater Mediator than Moses, a finished atonement at the cross, and a reigning King who has spoken to us plainly in His Son. How are the people in your local Sabbath School class reacting now that the quarterly is openly bringing up the YouTube critiques of Ellen White?

FORMER ADVENTISTS PHILIPPINES

​“Freed by the Gospel. Firm in the Word.”

Support this ministry

  • GCash: 0969-514-3944

  • PayPal: paypal.me/formeradventistsph


Comments

  1. Well well well. You certainly spent a lot of time to air your negative attitude towards Adventism. I hope it made you feel joyful and happy. I have found the living in " negativism" never makes a persons peaceful. I have also found that people who question and doubt and criticize are not happy people either. I wonder how you would contrast the old covenant and the new covenant. People seem to talk about the New covenant but don't define what it really is in comparison to the old.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I sense that your comment reflects more about your own perspective than this post. It does not use ad hominem attacks, and your response comes across as dismissive. I pray that God will soften your heart and guide you toward understanding.

      Delete

Post a Comment