"The Bible Still Calls It Sabbath!" (Lyk & Lei's Worst Lying Argument Ever!)



Lyk & Lei Liars asked:

"IF SUNDAY REPLACED THE SABBATH, WHY DOES THE BIBLE STILL CALL THE SEVENTH DAY THE SABBATH?"

Wow, of all the arguments they could have come up with, Lyk & Lei really chose this one? That's like asking, "If the Roman Empire fell, why do history books still call it the Roman Empire?" The question is funny because it assumes a name can't remain even when its covenantal role is being debated.

The SDA argument sounds persuasive until you notice a basic logical mistake: it assumes that if the covenantal Sabbath obligation ended, the seventh day itself must somehow disappear from the calendar.

But why would it? If the seventh day stopped being Saturday, then sure, you have a point. But that's not what Christians believe. Christians don't believe Sunday became the new seventh day. Christians believe the Old Covenant Sabbath has been fulfilled in Christ and is no longer binding as a covenant sign, while the Church gathers on the Lord's Day because of Christ's resurrection. Those are two completely different claims.

1. "God blessed the seventh day at Creation."

Genesis 2:3 says God blessed the seventh day. Agreed. But where does Genesis command Adam to keep a weekly Sabbath? The word "Sabbath" (shabbat) never appears in Genesis 2. The first command to observe a Sabbath doesn't appear until Israel receives manna in Exodus 16. This is a classic example of reading Sinai back into Eden.

By that logic:
  • Marriage existed in Eden.
  • Work existed in Eden.
  • Dominion existed in Eden.
Must we therefore conclude that every covenant regulation connected to those themes applies exactly the same way today? No. Creation foundations don't automatically mean covenant continuity.

2. "The Fourth Commandment identifies the seventh day."

Of course it does. Nobody disputes that. The question isn't: "Which day was the Sabbath under Moses?" The question is: "Are Christians under the Mosaic covenant?" Notice the SDA bait-and-switch. They answer a question nobody asked. Imagine this argument: "If animal sacrifices ended, why does Leviticus still call lambs sacrifices?" Because the text is describing what existed under that covenant.

The commandment still says seventh day because that's what Israel was commanded to observe. Why would the text suddenly rewrite itself?

3. Jesus Kept the Sabbath

Luke 4:16 says Jesus attended synagogue on the Sabbath. Of course He did. He was a Jew. He lived under the Law. Galatians 4:4 says Jesus was: "born under the law." Let's use the same logic elsewhere:
  • Jesus was circumcised.
  • Jesus kept Passover.
  • Jesus offered temple worship.
  • Jesus attended feasts.
  • Jesus wore tassels.
Should Christians do all those too? If not, why is Sabbath singled out? This is called special pleading. The SDA picks one part of Christ's Mosaic obedience and ignores the rest.

4. The Women Rested on the Sabbath After the Crucifixion

Luke 23:56 says the women rested according to the commandment. Again... What else would first-century Jewish women do? The New Covenant had not yet gone out into the world. Pentecost hadn't happened. The church wasn't even formally established. More importantly: Luke describing an event does not equal Luke prescribing a command. That's a descriptive fallacy. Just because something happened doesn't mean Christians are required to imitate it.

5. "Where Is the Explicit Change?"

This may be the weakest SDA argument. Let's turn it around.

BOOMERANG EFFECT

Where is the explicit verse saying:
  • The Day of Atonement is abolished?
  • Circumcision no longer required?
  • The Levitical priesthood ended?
  • The Temple system ended?
Find a verse saying: "The Fourth Commandment is hereby transferred from Saturday to Sunday." You won't. But then find a verse saying: "Animal sacrifices are hereby abolished effective immediately." You won't find that either.

The New Testament teaches these truths through redemptive-historical fulfillment, not through bureaucratic announcement memos. The SDA demands a standard they don't apply consistently elsewhere. That's called special pleading.

What Does the New Testament Actually Teach?

Colossians 2:16-17. Paul says: "Let no man judge you... regarding a festival, new moon, or sabbaths." The Greek sequence: festival, new moon, sabbaths matches the Old Testament formula for:
  • yearly observances
  • monthly observances
  • weekly observances
Paul calls them: "a shadow of things to come." The substance is Christ. Notice: Paul doesn't say, "Keep the Sabbath correctly." He says, "Don't let anyone judge you over it." That would be a very strange thing to say if Sabbath observance remained universally binding.

Romans 14:5.  Paul says: "One person esteems one day above another; another esteems every day alike." If Sabbath-keeping were still a universal moral requirement, Paul could never say this. Imagine saying: "One Christian thinks adultery is wrong; another doesn't. Let each be convinced." Impossible. Yet Paul allows liberty regarding days. Why? Because the covenantal Sabbath obligation had passed.

Hebrews 4.  The SDA often assumes Hebrews 4 teaches Sabbath-keeping. Yet the chapter repeatedly says the true rest is found in Christ. The Greek word sabbatismos points to God's ultimate rest, fulfilled in Christ and consummated in His kingdom. The author's conclusion isn't: "Go back to Saturday." The conclusion is: "Enter God's rest through faith."

The Funny Absurdity Test

Let's apply SDA reasoning consistently.

Analogy #1:  "If Jesus rode a donkey into Jerusalem, why do Christians drive cars?" Where is the verse replacing donkeys with Toyotas?

Analogy #2: "If Passover pointed to Christ, why does Exodus still call it Passover?" Because historical descriptions don't change when covenants change.

Analogy #3: "If circumcision ended, why does Genesis still call circumcision God's covenant sign?" Should the word magically disappear from the page?

Analogy #4:  "If sacrifices ended, why does Leviticus still call lambs sacrifices?" Because the Bible reports what God commanded under a previous covenant.

The argument collapses under its own weight.

Hebrew and Greek Reality Check

Hebrew: שַׁבָּת (Shabbat). Means cessation, rest, Sabbath. A word describing the seventh day doesn't prove perpetual covenant obligation. A calendar description is not a covenant argument.

Greek: σάββατον (Sabbaton).  The New Testament still calls the seventh day "Sabbath." Why wouldn't it? Saturday didn't stop being Saturday. The issue isn't terminology. The issue is covenant authority. The apostles never teach: "Gentile believers must keep the seventh-day Sabbath to remain faithful Christians." In Acts 15, when the Jerusalem Council addresses Gentile obligations, Sabbath observance is conspicuously absent. If Sabbath were the centerpiece of God's end-time test, that's a shocking omission.

Three Mic-Drop Cross-Examinations for Lyk & Lei Lies:

Question #1: If Sabbath-keeping is the seal of God's faithful people, why did the Jerusalem Council in Acts 15 not require Gentile converts to keep it? The perfect opportunity came and went. Silence.

Question #2:  Paul says, "Let no man judge you regarding sabbaths" (Col. 2:16). If weekly Sabbath observance remains binding, why does Paul prohibit Sabbath judgment instead of enforcing it?

Question #3: If Jesus keeping the Sabbath proves Christians must keep it, does Jesus being circumcised, offering sacrifices, attending feasts, and living under the Mosaic Law also prove Christians must do those things? If not, what objective rule excludes those but keeps the Sabbath?

Final Thought

The real question isn't: "Why does the Bible still call the seventh day the Sabbath?" The real question is: "Where do the apostles ever command New Covenant believers to keep the seventh-day Sabbath as a binding covenant obligation?"

The seventh day is still called the Sabbath for the same reason Egypt is still called Egypt, and Passover is still called Passover. Names remain. Covenants change. And according to the New Testament, the shadow has given way to the substance: Christ Himself is our rest. (Heb. 4:3-10)

FORMER ADVENTISTS PHILIPPINES

​“Freed by the Gospel. Firm in the Word.”

Support this ministry

  • GCash: 0969-514-3944

  • PayPal: paypal.me/formeradventistsph



Comments