Most Adventists were raised with a long list of strict dietary rules: no pork, no coffee, no tea, no spices, and the constant push to become full vegans. For a long time, many believed these rules came straight from heaven through Ellen G. White.
But let’s have some real talk. Now that we have access to modern medical science and a clearer understanding of the Bible, we have to ask: Were these health teachings really divine revelations, or just copied from the outdated health fads of the 1800s?
Let's break down some of Ellen White's top health rules and see how they hold up against modern science and the freedom we have in the New Covenant.
1. Is a Vegan Diet Really the "Superior" Christian Diet?
Ellen White constantly pushed for a vegan diet, claiming that eating meat "excites the animal passions" and lessens moral power. She even said meat increases the liability to disease by tenfold (1000%!).
"Flesh meat also tends to inflame the passions, and to lead to sensuality... Its use excites the animal passions to intense activity, and strengthens the lower propensities at the expense of the moral and intellectual powers." (Counsels on Diet and Foods (1938), Chapter 23 ("Flesh Meats"), Page 390)
"Flesh meat also tends to inflame the passions, and to lead to sensuality... Its use excites the animal passions to intense activity, and strengthens the lower propensities at the expense of the moral and intellectual powers." (Counsels on Diet and Foods (1938), Chapter 23 ("Flesh Meats"), Page 390)
The Science Update: Modern nutrition science tells a completely different story. While eating lots of highly processed meats isn't great, natural, healthy meat provides high-quality complete proteins, Zinc, and Vitamin B12, which are crucial for brain development. In fact, forcing growing kids onto strict vegan diets without careful supplementation can cause severe nutritional deficiencies and stunt their growth. Science shows that vegans don't inherently outlive meat-eaters. You can enjoy a hearty plate of chicken curry, biryani, or your favorite adobo, and still live a long, healthy life.
2. The Great Coffee and Milk Tea Ban
White called tea and coffee "poisonous" and claimed they ruin your physical, mental, and moral powers. She even taught that drinking coffee opens the door to alcohol and tobacco addiction.
“Tea is poisonous to the system. Christians should let it alone. The influence of coffee is in a degree the same as tea, but the effect upon the system is still worse.” (Testimonies for the Church, Vol. 2, pp. 64–65 (1868)
“Tea is poisonous to the system. Christians should let it alone. The influence of coffee is in a degree the same as tea, but the effect upon the system is still worse.” (Testimonies for the Church, Vol. 2, pp. 64–65 (1868)
“Tea, coffee, and tobacco, as well as alcoholic drinks, are different degrees in the scale of artificial stimulants. The effect of tea and coffee… tends in the same direction as that of wine and cider, liquor and tobacco.” (Review and Herald, July 29, 1884; reprinted in Counsels on Diet and Foods, p. 421)
The Science Update: Try telling a Filipino college student pulling an all-nighter that their iced coffee or milk tea is destroying their morals! Science has proven caffeine doesn't incite "baser passions." In fact, coffee is one of the most heavily researched beverages in history. Moderate coffee drinking actually reduces the risk of type 2 diabetes, liver cancer, and Parkinson's disease. Green and black teas are packed with antioxidants that fight cancer and protect the heart. So, whether you are enjoying an Ilocano brew, a matcha latte, or a refreshing glass of lassi and tea in a Makati restaurant, you are actually doing your body a favor.
3. Will Suka, Bawang, and Spices Ruin Your Soul?
Imagine a Filipino kitchen without garlic (bawang), ginger (luya), vinegar (suka), or black pepper. Ellen White warned that spices and condiments irritate the stomach, make the blood "feverish," and arouse animal propensities. She literally called people who eat pepper and mustard "self-murderers" and said pickles shouldn't enter the human stomach.
“Spices at first irritate the tender coats of the stomach, but finally destroy the natural sensibility of this delicate membrane. The blood becomes feverish, the animal propensities are aroused, while the moral and intellectual powers are weakened and become servants to the baser passions.” (Spiritual Gifts, Vol. 4a, p. 130 (1864)
“Mustard, pepper, spices, pickles, and other things of a like character irritate the stomach and make the blood feverish and impure. They inflame the animal passions, and do not tend to bring the system into a healthy condition. Those who use such things are self‑murderers.” (Testimonies for the Church, Vol. 2, p. 369 (1868)
“Spices at first irritate the tender coats of the stomach, but finally destroy the natural sensibility of this delicate membrane. The blood becomes feverish, the animal propensities are aroused, while the moral and intellectual powers are weakened and become servants to the baser passions.” (Spiritual Gifts, Vol. 4a, p. 130 (1864)
“Mustard, pepper, spices, pickles, and other things of a like character irritate the stomach and make the blood feverish and impure. They inflame the animal passions, and do not tend to bring the system into a healthy condition. Those who use such things are self‑murderers.” (Testimonies for the Church, Vol. 2, p. 369 (1868)
The Science Update: This is where 19th-century folk medicine really shows its age. Your stomach is highly acidic; it doesn't "ferment" or putrefy food just because you added a vinaigrette to your salad. Furthermore, spices are superfoods! Ginger doesn't harm the stomach; it's a proven remedy for nausea and indigestion. Garlic lowers blood pressure and fights infections. Fermented foods like pickles actually provide probiotics that improve your gut microbiome and digestion.
4. The Pandesal Problem: Baking Soda and Milk
White taught that using baking soda or baking powder in bread is "harmful and unnecessary," claiming it poisons the entire system. She also said we shouldn't use milk in bread because it ferments in the stomach.
“Soda or baking powder, in bread, is harmful and unnecessary. It poisons the entire system.” (Testimonies for the Church, Vol. 2, p. 391 (1868) “Milk, used in bread, ferments in the stomach, and produces very disagreeable effects. It is better to dispense with it altogether in bread making.” (Testimonies for the Church, Vol. 2, p. 68 (1868)
“Soda or baking powder, in bread, is harmful and unnecessary. It poisons the entire system.” (Testimonies for the Church, Vol. 2, p. 391 (1868) “Milk, used in bread, ferments in the stomach, and produces very disagreeable effects. It is better to dispense with it altogether in bread making.” (Testimonies for the Church, Vol. 2, p. 68 (1868)
The Science Update: If this were true, our daily morning pandesal would be a national health crisis! Chemically speaking, baking soda is neutralized during baking. It doesn't poison you or inflame your stomach. And because the stomach is a highly acidic chamber, milk bread digests perfectly fine without "fermenting" into alcohol inside you.
5. Two Meals a Day for Babies?!
Perhaps the most dangerous advice Ellen White gave was about infants. She wrote that babies should only eat at regular periods, "not oftener than three times a day, and two meals would be better than three."
“Children should eat at regular periods, not oftener than three times a day, and two meals would be better than three. Nothing should be eaten between meals.” (Testimonies for the Church, Vol. 2, p. 352 (1868)
“Children should eat at regular periods, not oftener than three times a day, and two meals would be better than three. Nothing should be eaten between meals.” (Testimonies for the Church, Vol. 2, p. 352 (1868)
The Science Update: Any Filipino lola or modern pediatrician would be horrified by this. The American Academy of Pediatrics and modern medicine strictly advise feeding infants on demand. Babies have tiny stomachs and need to eat every few hours (sometimes 8 to 12 times a day) to survive and develop properly. Limiting an infant to two meals a day is starvation, plain and simple.
6. Don't Mix Fruits and Veggies?
White made it a dietary rule that "vegetables and fruit should not be eaten at the same meal," claiming it causes brain confusion and destroys your "vital force."
“Vegetables and fruit should not be eaten at the same meal. At one meal use vegetables, at another fruit. The combination of the two often produces dyspepsia. Serious results ensue, and the mind becomes confused; the vital force is lessened.” (Testimonies for the Church, Vol. 2, p. 373 (1868)
“Vegetables and fruit should not be eaten at the same meal. At one meal use vegetables, at another fruit. The combination of the two often produces dyspepsia. Serious results ensue, and the mind becomes confused; the vital force is lessened.” (Testimonies for the Church, Vol. 2, p. 373 (1868)
The Science Update: So, no tomatoes and kangkong in your sinigang? No eating a slice of mango after your meal? The "food combining" myth has been completely debunked. The human digestive tract releases multiple enzymes simultaneously (amylase, protease, lipase) specifically designed to process complex, mixed meals all at once.
Real Talk Reflection
"For the kingdom of God is not a matter of eating and drinking, but of righteousness, peace and joy in the Holy Spirit." Romans 14:17
When we look at the overwhelming scientific evidence, it becomes incredibly clear: Ellen White’s health teachings were not years ahead of science. They were heavily borrowed from the faulty, unscientific health reformers of her era.
But as believers, we have an even greater truth to stand on. From a New Covenant Theology perspective, we know that the cross changed everything. Jesus Himself declared all foods clean (Mark 7:19). The Old Covenant dietary laws, and certainly the extra-biblical 19th-century rules of Ellen White, are not binding on the Christian today.
We are not saved, sanctified, or made holy by perfectly avoiding meat, skipping our morning coffee, or separating our fruits and vegetables. True sanctification is the work of the Holy Spirit, not the result of a strict vegan diet. Under the New Covenant, our relationship with God is built entirely on the finished work of Christ, not on our adherence to a set of physical food laws.
Call to Action: Let go of the guilt and fear tied to what's on your plate. Enjoy your meals with a heart full of thanksgiving! Take care of your body using the solid, evidence-based science we have today, but always remember that your spiritual standing before God rests on grace alone. Walk in that freedom today!
FORMER ADVENTISTS PHILIPPINES
“Freed by the Gospel. Firm in the Word.”
For more inquiries, contact us:
Email: formeradventist.ph@gmail.com
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/formeradventistph
Partner with me in advancing this ministry. Be part of this mission! Your support helps us continue gospel-centered outreach and resources.
• GCash: 0969-514-3944
• PayPal: paypal.me/formeradventistsph
• Ko-Fi: ko-fi.com/ronaldobidos
No comments:
Post a Comment