Let’s be real for a second. As Christians, our faith has to rest fully on what Jesus already accomplished and on the solid truth of God’s Word, not on shaky human predictions. Anytime someone claims to speak directly for God, especially about the exact timing of Christ’s return or end‑time events, we’re called by Scripture itself to test those claims against both the Bible and history.
What follows is a Q&A that digs into the record of failed end‑time predictions, shifting theories, and “revised visions” tied to Ellen G. White and the early Adventist movement.
Q1: How did Ellen White get involved in setting dates for Christ’s return?
Answer: Back in the early 1840s, Ellen Harmon (who later became Ellen White) was just a teenager but already deeply caught up in the Millerite movement. William Miller had predicted that Jesus would return sometime between March 21, 1843, and March 21, 1844. When nothing happened, his associate Samuel S. Snow pushed a new date: October 22, 1844. Ellen, along with thousands of others, fully bought into this expectation.
But when October 22 came and went, the infamous “Great Disappointment,” many didn’t immediately give up on date‑setting. Instead, new theories popped up:
The Tarrying Time: Samuel Snow pointed to Habakkuk 2:3, saying they were just in a short “delay” while Christ finished His journey.
The Fourth Watch: James White and others leaned on Luke 12:35–40, claiming Jesus would come during the “fourth watch” of the night, setting sights on October 1845.
The Jubilee Year: Some argued that the Jubilee trumpet had sounded in October 1844, meaning the real end would be October 1845.
By late 1845, most Millerites had abandoned the whole date‑setting game. But a small group, the “Shut Door” Adventists led by Joseph Bates, James White, and Ellen Harmon kept pushing the idea that Christ’s return was still just around the corner.
Q2: Did Ellen White really predict short‑term dates for Christ’s return after 1844?
Answer: Yes, and we have firsthand testimony to prove it. Lucinda Burdick, who personally knew James and Ellen White in Maine around 1845, described a clear pattern of failed predictions and quick reinterpretations.
She recalled:
“I got to know James White and Ellen Harmon early in 1845… She claimed God showed her things that didn’t happen. At one point she said the Lord would come in June 1845. When June passed, she explained that she had misunderstood ‘the language of Canaan’, that it actually meant September 1845. September came and went, and we still haven’t seen the Lord.”
Burdick noticed three repeating patterns in Ellen’s early ministry:
Shifting Dates: When one prediction failed, it was re‑framed as a misunderstanding and moved to the next month.
Unfulfilled Persecution Visions: She predicted she and her group would be jailed in eastern Maine, but nothing happened, and the vision was quietly dropped.
Reversal of Eternal Standing: People she once claimed to see wearing “brilliant crowns” in heaven were later declared “lost forever” once they questioned her authority.
Even James White backed up the timeline. In A Word to the Little Flock (1847, p. 22), he admitted:
“It is well known that many were expecting the Lord to come at the 7th month, 1845. That Christ would then come, we firmly believed.”
Q3: How did Ellen White respond to Joseph Bates’ “Seven‑Year Sanctuary” theory (1851)?
Answer: After the failed dates of 1844 and 1845, Joseph Bates came up with a new idea in 1850. He argued that the “antitypical Day of Atonement” would last exactly seven years, starting in October 1844 and ending in October 1851 with Christ’s return.
During this period, Ellen White reported several visions that fueled the belief that time was almost up:
Nov 18, 1848 (Dorchester Vision): She said, “The time of trouble has commenced… the reason why the four winds have not let go is because the saints are not all sealed.”
“The angels are holding the four winds. It is God that restrains the powers. The angels have not let go, for the saints are not all sealed. The time of trouble has commenced. It is begun. The reason why the four winds have not let go is because the saints are not all sealed. It's on the increase, and will increase more and more; the trouble will never end until the earth is rid of the wick ed.” (Published by Joseph Bates in his book/pamphlet A Seal of the Living God, pp. 24-26) September 1, 1849 Cholera Epidemic: She warned, “What we have seen of the pestilence is but the beginning… soon the dead and dying will be all around us.”
"What we have seen and heard of the pestilence is but the beginning of what we shall see and hear. Soon the dead and dying will be all around us. I saw that some will be so hardened, as to even make sport of the judgments of God. Then the slain of the Lord will be from one end of the earth to the other; they will not be lamented, gathered, nor buried; but their ill savor will come up from the face of the whole earth. Those only who have the seal of the living God will be shelteredfrom the storm of wrath that will soon fall on the heads of those who have rejected the truth." ( The Present Truth (Vol. 1, No. 4), p. 32)
Note: When this vision was later condensed and republished i n the book Early Writings on page 37, the specific prediction that "soon the dead and dying will be all around us" was omitted. Jan 31, 1849: She rebuked believers who thought Christ’s coming was still years away.
"I saw some, looking too far off for the coming of the Lord. Time has continued on a few years longer than they expected; therefore they think it may continue a few years more, and in this way their minds are being led from present truth, out after the world. In these things I saw great danger; for if the mind is filled with other things, present truth is shut out, and there is no place in our foreheads for the seal of the living God." ("To Those who are receiving the seal of the living God" later republished in the book Early Writings (1882), p. 58) June 27, 1850: She wrote, “Time is almost finished. Get ready, get ready, get ready… what we have been years learning, they will have to learn in a few months.”
"In a view given June 27, 1850, my accompanying angel said, 'Time is almost finished. Do you reflect the lovely image of Jesus as you should?' Then I was pointed to the earth and saw that there would have to
be a getting ready among those who have of late embraced the third angel’s message. Said the angel, 'Ge t ready, get ready, get rea dy. Ye will have to die a greater death to the world than ye have ever yet died.' I saw that the re w as a great work to do for them and but little time in wh ich to do it. But now time is almost finished, and what we have been years learning, they will have to learn in a few months. They will also have much to unlearn and much to learn again." (A Sketch of the Christian Experience and Views of Ellen G. White (1851) later republished in the book Early Writings (1882), p.64, 67) September 1850: She claimed Jesus’ time in the Most Holy Place was “nearly finished” and could not last much longer.
"Some are looking too far off for the coming of the Lord. Time has continued a few years longer than they expected; therefore they think it may continue a few years more. [...] I saw that the time for Jesus to be in the most holy place was nearly finished and that time c an last but a very little longer. What leisure time we have should be spent in searching the Bible, which is to judge us in t he last day." ( A Sketch of the Christian Experience and Views of Ellen G. White (1851) later republished in the book Early Writings (1882), p. 58)
Q4: Did Ellen White make a clear false prophecy at the 1856 Conference?
Answer: Yes, this is one of the most direct examples. At the Battle Creek Conference in May 1856, Ellen White claimed a vision where an angel told her about the very people in that room:
Some would die naturally (“food for worms”).
Some would live to suffer the Seven Last Plagues.
Some would still be alive at Christ’s Second Coming and be translated without seeing death.
There were 67 believers present. But history tells the story: by 1943, Dr. John Harvey Kellogg, who had attended as a child, was the last survivor, and he too died. Every single attendee passed away without seeing the plagues or the Second Coming.
This creates a major theological problem. Jesus Himself said in Matthew 24:36 that no one knows the day or hour, not even the angels. If God’s angels don’t know the timeline, then one could not have truthfully given Ellen White a generational prophecy. And if God alone knows the timing, He would not inspire an angel to deliver an expectation that turned out false.
Q5: How did Ellen White handle end‑time concepts when early expectations failed?
Answer: Whenever the timelines she and her followers expected didn’t pan out, Ellen White shifted the meaning of key end‑time ideas, moving them from “already happening” to “still future.” Here are some examples:
Time of Trouble
Early (1848): “The time of trouble has commenced, it is begun.”
Later: “The time of trouble… had not yet commenced.” (1849) → eventually pushed far into the future in Great Controversy (1888).
1878 Generation
Claimed most of the youth of 1878 would die before the time of trouble.
Reality: they lived normal lifespans into old age.
Fall of Babylon
Early (1853): “I saw the nominal churches had fallen.”
Later (1911): “Not yet… can it be said that Babylon is fallen.”
The Shaking
Early (1850): “The mighty shaking has commenced.”
Later: “The shaking must soon take place.” (1860) → reframed again in 1899 as just beginning.
The Loud Cry
Announced as happening in 1892.
By 1899: said it was “smothered.”
By 1904/1906: pushed back into the future.
The Latter Rain
1897: urged believers to pray “now, in the time of the latter rain.”
1906: reframed as something still to look forward to.
Groveling of Opponents
1844: predicted those who rejected Miller’s message would grovel at Adventists’ feet.
Later: re‑applied to Sabbath‑keepers vs. Sunday‑keepers (1854, 1868, 1912).
In short, whenever the prophecies failed in real time, Ellen White simply re‑dated or re‑framed them as future events, creating a moving target that kept followers expecting but never seeing fulfillment.
Q6: What other specific time‑based and global predictions failed?
Answer: Several of Ellen White’s prophecies tied to timelines or worldwide events simply didn’t happen:
Night Watch Calculations (1868–1886)
Claimed the church had passed through the “first,” “second,” and “third” watches, with Christ expected in the “fourth watch” (1873–1886).
By 1886 she wrote, “The coming of the Lord draweth nigh… we have but a little time.”
The timeline expired with no return.
The Sunday Law Generation (1888–1889)
During U.S. debates over Sunday legislation, she said her contemporaries would live to see the final crisis and Christ’s return.
“Some of us who now believe will be alive… and shall see the prediction verified.”
Reality: everyone present died decades ago without seeing it.
Premature Pouring of the Plagues (1901)
Earlier (1864) she said the plagues couldn’t fall while Jesus was still in the heavenly sanctuary.
But in 1901 she wrote, “Already the plagues of God are beginning to be poured out.”
This created a direct contradiction: either probation had closed, or her earlier vision was wrong.
Imminent Depopulation of the Earth (1860s)
Claimed humanity was degenerating so fast that the earth would soon be depopulated.
In reality, global population grew from 1.3 billion in the 1860s to over 8 billion today, thanks to advances in health and medicine.
In short, her time‑bound and global predictions consistently failed, either collapsing under their own deadlines or being contradicted by history and science.
FORMER ADVENTISTS PHILIPPINES
“Freed by the Gospel. Firm in the Word.”
For more inquiries, contact us:
Email: formeradventist.ph@gmail.com
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/formeradventistph
Partner with me in advancing this ministry. Be part of this mission! Your support helps us continue gospel-centered outreach and resources.
• GCash: 0969-514-3944
• PayPal: paypal.me/formeradventistsph
• Ko-Fi: ko-fi.com/ronaldobidos
No comments:
Post a Comment