Introduction
While SDA Fundamental Belief #9 contains many orthodox affirmations about Christ's atoning work, a careful examination through historico-grammatical hermeneutics reveals several theological concerns and distinctive emphases that warrant critical engagement. From the biblical perspective, we must evaluate whether this statement properly represents the biblical testimony regarding the scope, nature, and efficacy of Christ's atonement.
Point-by-Point Analysis and Critique
1. "Perfect obedience to God's will": The Nature of Christ's Active Obedience
SDA Position: Christ's "perfect obedience to God's will" is presented as part of the atoning provision.
Critique: While this statement is essentially correct, it requires clarification. Christ's active obedience (His perfect law-keeping) and passive obedience (His suffering and death) together constitute the righteousness imputed to believers (Romans 5:18-19). However, Adventism's emphasis on obedience often conflates Christ's perfect obedience with a requirement for believers to achieve sinless perfection before Christ's return, a doctrine not found in this statement but prevalent in wider SDA theology.
Greek Exegesis: In Romans 5:19, Paul uses hypēkoē (ὑπακοή, "obedience") to describe how "through the obedience of the one man the many will be made righteous." This is Christ's obedience credited to us, not a pattern we must perfectly replicate. The aorist passive katastathēsontai (καταστασθήσονται) indicates a forensic declaration, not a process of moral transformation requiring our sinless obedience.
New Covenant Perspective: Under the New Covenant, Christ fulfills all righteousness on our behalf (Matthew 3:15). Believers are not under the Mosaic Law as a covenant of works but receive Christ's righteousness by faith alone (2 Corinthians 5:21).
2. "God provided the only means of atonement": Exclusivity of the Cross
SDA Position: The statement correctly affirms the exclusivity of Christ's atonement.
Affirmation with Caveat: This is biblically sound (Acts 4:12; 1 Timothy 2:5). However, SDA theology elsewhere introduces Christ's ongoing "investigative judgment" ministry beginning in 1844, which functionally makes the cross insufficient without Christ's additional heavenly tribunal work. This contradicts Hebrews 9:12, where Christ "entered once for all into the holy places... by means of his own blood, thus securing an eternal redemption" (ἐφάπαξ, ephapax - "once for all").
Hebrew Background: The Day of Atonement typology (Leviticus 16) is fulfilled completely in Christ's once-for-all sacrifice (Hebrews 9:26-28). The Greek tetelestai (τετέλεσται, "It is finished," John 19:30) is a perfect passive indicative, indicating completed action with ongoing results; the atonement is finished, not continuing.
3. "The whole creation may better understand... the infinite and holy love of the Creator."
SDA Position: The atonement serves a cosmic, educational purpose, helping the universe understand God's character.
Critique: While Scripture does present cosmic dimensions to redemption (Colossians 1:20; Ephesians 3:10), the primary SDA emphasis on the atonement as a "vindication" or "demonstration" to watching heavenly beings reflects their Great Controversy theme more than biblical priority. This can subtly shift focus from the atonement's saving efficacy to its didactic function.
Biblical Priority: The primary purpose of the atonement is reconciliation and propitiation (Romans 3:25; 1 John 2:2). The Greek hilastērion (ἱλαστήριον) refers to the mercy seat where God's wrath is satisfied. While the atonement does reveal God's character (Romans 5:8), its essential purpose is to deal with sin's guilt and penalty, not merely to educate angels.
New Covenant Theology: The focus is on the vertical dimension, reconciling sinners to God, rather than the horizontal/cosmic dimension of explaining God to the universe.
4. "This perfect atonement vindicates the righteousness of God's law."
SDA Position: The atonement vindicates God's law.
Critical Analysis: This statement reflects a central Adventist theme: Christ died to vindicate the perpetual, unchanging nature of the Ten Commandments, particularly the Sabbath. However, this creates a law-centered rather than Christ-centered atonement theology.
Greek Exegesis: Romans 3:25-26 does speak of God's righteousness being demonstrated (endeixin, ἔνδειξιν), but the context is God's judicial righteousness in passing over former sins and now justifying believers through faith. The passage is about God's justice in salvation, not about vindicating the Decalogue's permanent authority.
New Covenant Perspective: Under New Covenant Theology, Christ fulfills the Mosaic Law, bringing it to its appointed end as a covenant administration (Romans 10:4; Galatians 3:23-25). The atonement doesn't vindicate the Mosaic Law's continuing authority; rather, it establishes the "law of Christ" (Galatians 6:2; 1 Corinthians 9:21). The Greek telos (τέλος) in Romans 10:4 means "goal" or "end." Christ is both the law's culmination and termination as a covenant system.
Hebrew Context: Jeremiah 31:31-34 prophesies a "new covenant" explicitly different from the Mosaic covenant. Hebrews 8:13 declares the old covenant "obsolete" (Greek gerasken, γεράσκαν, "aging/becoming obsolete"). The atonement inaugurates this new covenant, not the vindication of the old.
5. "The death of Christ is substitutionary and expiatory, reconciling and transforming."
SDA Position: Christ's death is substitutionary and expiatory.
Strong Affirmation: This is thoroughly biblical and commendable. Penal substitutionary atonement is clearly taught in Scripture (Isaiah 53:5-6; 2 Corinthians 5:21; Galatians 3:13).
Greek Support:
- Hilasmos (ἱλασμός, "propitiation," 1 John 2:2) indicates Christ's death satisfies God's wrath against sin.
- Katallassō (καταλλάσσω, "reconcile," 2 Corinthians 5:18-19) shows the restoration of the relationship between God and humanity.
- Antilytron (ἀντίλυτρον, "ransom," 1 Timothy 2:6) emphasizes substitution.
Pastoral Application: This aspect of the statement should be enthusiastically affirmed in any orthodox Christian theology.
6. "The bodily resurrection of Christ proclaims God's triumph over the forces of evil."
SDA Position: The resurrection demonstrates God's victory over evil.
Affirmation: Absolutely biblical (1 Corinthians 15:54-57; Colossians 2:15). The resurrection is the Father's vindication of the Son and proof of accepted atonement (Romans 4:25).
Greek Exegesis: In 1 Corinthians 15:20, Christ is called aparchē (ἀπαρχή, "firstfruits"), guaranteeing the future resurrection of all believers. The resurrection is integral to the gospel (1 Corinthians 15:3-4) and demonstrates Christ's victory over death (Greek katargeō, καταργέω, "abolish/destroy," 2 Timothy 1:10).
Continuationist Perspective: The resurrection power continues in the church through the Holy Spirit, who raised Jesus from the dead (Romans 8:11), empowering believers for ministry and spiritual gifts today.
7. "For those who accept the atonement, it assures their final victory over sin and death."
SDA Position: Those who "accept the atonement" receive final victory.
Concern - Conditional Security: The phrase "those who accept" could reflect Arminian soteriology (which I hold), but in SDA theology, this often implies ongoing investigative judgment where acceptance must be maintained through obedience until Christ's return. This creates uncertainty about final salvation.
Biblical Balance: While Reformed Arminians affirm conditional security (apostasy is possible through willful, persistent unbelief), Scripture also gives strong assurance to those presently trusting Christ (John 5:24; Romans 8:38-39; 1 John 5:13). The Greek perfect tense in John 5:24 (metabebēken, μεταβέβηκεν, "has passed") indicates permanent transition from death to life for believers.
New Covenant Assurance: Under the New Covenant, God promises to complete the work He began (Philippians 1:6). While believers must persevere in faith, assurance is grounded in Christ's finished work, not in passing an investigative judgment.
8. "It declares the Lordship of Jesus Christ, before whom every knee in heaven and on earth will bow."
SDA Position: The resurrection establishes Christ's universal Lordship.
Strong Affirmation: Philippians 2:9-11 clearly teaches Christ's exaltation and universal acknowledgment. The Greek kyrios (κύριος, "Lord") applied to Jesus (verse 11) is the LXX translation of YHWH, affirming Christ's deity.
Postmillennial Perspective: This cosmic Lordship is progressively manifested as the gospel advances throughout history, culminating in Christ's return when every knee bows willingly (believers) or unwillingly (unbelievers). The resurrection inaugurates Christ's reign, which will continue until all enemies are subdued (1 Corinthians 15:25).
Major Theological Concerns with the SDA Framework
A. The Great Controversy Paradigm
While not explicitly mentioned in this statement, SDA theology interprets the atonement primarily through the "Great Controversy" lens, a cosmic conflict between Christ and Satan. This framework, though containing some biblical elements, can distort the atonement's essential nature:
Biblical Priority: The atonement is first about satisfying God's justice and wrath against sin (propitiation), not primarily about winning a cosmic debate. Romans 3:25-26 focuses on God's righteousness being upheld, not on vindicating His character before angels.
B. The Investigative Judgment
Though not mentioned here, SDA theology teaches that since 1844, Christ has been conducting an investigative judgment in heaven, examining believers' works to determine who is worthy of salvation. This doctrine:
Contradicts Hebrews 9:12, 26-28: Christ entered the heavenly sanctuary "once for all" (ephapax, ἐφάπαξ), securing eternal redemption. There is no ongoing judicial investigation.
Undermines Assurance: Believers cannot know their standing until the investigation concludes, contradicting 1 John 5:13, where John writes "so that you may know (Greek eidēte, εἰδῆτε, perfect subjunctive) that you have eternal life."
C. Law-Centered vs. Christ-Centered Atonement
SDA theology makes the atonement serve the purpose of vindicating the Decalogue's permanent authority, particularly the seventh-day Sabbath. However:
New Covenant Reality: Christ Himself is our Sabbath rest (Matthew 11:28; Hebrews 4:9-10, where sabbatismos, σαββατισμός, refers to the rest found in Christ). Colossians 2:16-17 explicitly identifies Sabbaths as "shadows" fulfilled in Christ.
Greek Analysis: Colossians 2:16-17 uses the present imperative krinetō (κρινέτω, "let judge") with the negative mē (μή), commanding "let no one judge you" regarding Sabbaths. The phrase "but the body belongs to Christ" (verse 17) indicates Christ is the sōma (σῶμα, "substance/reality") of which Sabbaths were mere skia (σκιά, "shadow").
Conclusion and Pastoral Application
SDA Fundamental Belief #9 contains much orthodox Christian teaching about the atonement, particularly regarding substitutionary atonement and Christ's bodily resurrection. However, several concerns emerge when examined closely:
- The statement's emphasis on "vindicating God's law" reflects a law-centered rather than Christ-centered focus.
- The educational/cosmic purpose of the atonement is emphasized at the potential expense of its saving purpose.
- The broader SDA framework (Great Controversy, Investigative Judgment) undermines the finality and sufficiency of Christ's finished work.
From a New Covenant Theology perspective, we affirm that Christ's death and resurrection have inaugurated the New Covenant, fulfilling and superseding the Mosaic administration. The atonement is complete, Christ's work is finished (tetelestai), and believers can have full assurance in His accomplished redemption.
From a Continuationist perspective, the resurrection power continues through the Holy Spirit's ongoing ministry in the church, empowering believers to witness, serve, and exercise spiritual gifts until Christ's return.
Grave Pastoral Concern: The wider Seventh-day Adventist theological system, particularly through its doctrines of investigative judgment, Sabbath-keeping as the seal of God, and emphasis on achieving character perfection before Christ's return, constitutes a false gospel that fundamentally contradicts salvation by grace alone through faith alone in Christ alone. Paul's warning in Galatians 1:6-9 is directly applicable: "I am astonished that you are so quickly deserting him who called you in the grace of Christ and are turning to a different gospel—not that there is another one, but there are some who trouble you and want to distort the gospel of Christ."
The SDA system teaches a works-based salvation where one's eternal destiny depends not solely on Christ's finished work, but on passing an investigative judgment based on one's record of obedience, particularly Sabbath observance. This is precisely the Galatian error, adding law-keeping to grace as necessary for salvation (Galatians 5:2-4). When any system requires human works, observances, or character perfection as conditions for final justification, it has "fallen away from grace" and made "Christ of no advantage" (Galatians 5:4).
This is not a mere theological difference it is another gospel entirely. Scripture is unambiguous: "For by grace you have been saved through faith. And this is not your own doing; it is the gift of God, not a result of works, so that no one may boast" (Ephesians 2:8-9). The Greek construction (te gar chariti este sesōsmenoi, τῇ γὰρ χάριτι ἐστε σεσῳσμένοι) uses the perfect passive participle sesōsmenoi (σεσῳσμένοι), indicating completed salvation with ongoing results, not salvation pending investigative review.
We must therefore call SDA adherents to abandon this false gospel and embrace the true gospel of Jesus Christ: salvation fully accomplished at the cross, received by faith alone, apart from works of law (Romans 3:28). The sufficiency of the cross and the completeness of Christ's atonement demand we reject any system requiring investigative judgment, law-keeping, or character perfection as conditions for final salvation. Christ alone, by grace alone, through faith alone—nothing added, nothing required, nothing pending.
Former Adventists Philippines
“Freed by the Gospel. Firm in the Word.”
For more inquiries, contact us:
Email: formeradventist.ph@gmail.com
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/formeradventistph
Former Adventists Philippines Association, Inc
SEC Registration No: 2025090219381-03
Help keep this content free for everyone. I am committed to sharing these truths and resources freely. If you have found value in my articles since 2021 and would like to partner with me in this ministry, your support on Ko-fi would be greatly appreciated. It helps cover the costs of maintaining this blog and creating new content.
❤️ Partner with me on Ko-fi
Gcash# 09695143944
PayPal: paypal.me/backtothescriptures
Ko-Fi: https://ko-fi.com/ronaldobidos
No comments:
Post a Comment